Repository logo

Infoscience

  • English
  • French
Log In
Logo EPFL, École polytechnique fédérale de Lausanne

Infoscience

  • English
  • French
Log In
  1. Home
  2. Academic and Research Output
  3. EPFL thesis
  4. Action Levers towards Sustainable Wellbeing: Re-Thinking Negative Emissions, Sufficiency, Deliberative Democracy
 
doctoral thesis

Action Levers towards Sustainable Wellbeing: Re-Thinking Negative Emissions, Sufficiency, Deliberative Democracy

Nick, Sascha  
2023

Systems theory defines leverage points as places to intervene in order to change a system. Points with high impact on system behavior are notoriously hard to act upon, and indeed most policy intervention is based at the lowest level (#12 in Donella Meadows' order), via subsidies, taxes, or standards. This thesis explores how some of our most pressing issues, especially climate, biodiversity, or inequality, could be effectively solved using "action levers", coordinated action on multiple leverage points, like mindset (#2), system goal (#3), power to change system structure (#4), or rules (#5). Three action levers are identified, explored and partly tested: Negative Emissions, Sufficiency, Deliberative Democracy.

If suitably governed, Negative Emissions could reverse their current effect of extending the fossil era and its power relations and, while limited to perhaps 10% of current emissions, significantly accelerate decarbonization - a beneficial case of the "tail wagging the dog". We modeled two cases, Switzerland and global aviation, and found that an effective 1.5°C-compatible climate policy is affordable and accelerates today's strategies by more than a decade. Through a polluter-financed public fund, investing in nature-based solutions with biodiversity and societal co-benefits, several defining elements of society could be durably changed: democratizing governance, transferring wealth from corporations to communities, avoiding technological lock-in, and building purpose and identity. To test implementation with today's laws, we are preparing a voluntary 1%-scale pilot fund.

Sufficiency is central to any sustainable society. Since May 2022, as part of the SFOE SWICE project, frameworks for wellbeing, human needs, provisioning systems, and resource use were developed, to ensure consistency of the whole consortium, including its living labs. Furthermore, qualitative analysis of attitudes towards sufficiency has been conducted in stakeholder workshops. This will be the basis for quantitative analysis and modeling, building on this thesis - aiming to rethink the Swiss habitat, its satisfiers and provisioning systems, towards wellbeing for all with a much lower resource footprint.

Deliberative Democracy, in countless citizens' assemblies since the 1980s, reached remarkable convergence on complex topics linked to values, impacting human lives. However, it proved difficult to engage the population which has not participated in the assembly. On this foundation of active learning and facilitated deliberation, where knowledge and shared values emerge, we developed the theory, process, and IT tools of a universal "Academic Citizens' Assembly". It has been successfully conducted five times, with 20-200 participants, online and in three cities, on topics like energy, food, health, sufficiency, and climate policy, with final convergence >80% on the main proposals. A commune-scale assembly is in discussion for 2024.

Outreach to citizens and policymakers was developed for all policy-relevant results. Several limitations remain: the role of fossil fuel bans, needed public investments, quantification of a transition towards sufficiency, or how to build acceptance and integrate deliberative assemblies into the political system. Still, the conclusion is clear: the three action levers can be effective, and reinforce each other.

  • Files
  • Details
  • Metrics
Type
doctoral thesis
DOI
10.5075/epfl-thesis-10487
Author(s)
Nick, Sascha  
Advisors
Thalmann, Philippe  
Jury

Prof. Brice Tanguy Alphonse Lecampion (président) ; Prof. Philippe Thalmann (directeur de thèse) ; Prof. Irmi Seidl, Prof. Julia Steinberger, Prof. Guido Palazzo (rapporteurs)

Date Issued

2023

Publisher

EPFL

Publisher place

Lausanne

Public defense year

2023-06-28

Thesis number

10487

Total of pages

256

Subjects

climate action

•

net zero

•

negative emissions

•

wellbeing

•

human needs

•

sufficiency

•

deliberative democracy

•

leverage points

•

systems thinking

•

engaging society

EPFL units
LEURE  
Faculty
ENAC  
School
IA  
Doctoral School
EDCE  
Available on Infoscience
June 22, 2023
Use this identifier to reference this record
https://infoscience.epfl.ch/handle/20.500.14299/198557
Logo EPFL, École polytechnique fédérale de Lausanne
  • Contact
  • infoscience@epfl.ch

  • Follow us on Facebook
  • Follow us on Instagram
  • Follow us on LinkedIn
  • Follow us on X
  • Follow us on Youtube
AccessibilityLegal noticePrivacy policyCookie settingsEnd User AgreementGet helpFeedback

Infoscience is a service managed and provided by the Library and IT Services of EPFL. © EPFL, tous droits réservés