Presentation / Talk

Scaled False Discovery Proportion and Related Error Metrics

In multiple testing, a variety of control metrics of false positives have been introduced such as the Per Family Error Rate (PFER), Family-Wise Error Rate (FWER), the False Discovery Rate (FDR), the False Exceedence Rate (FER). In this talk, we present a comprehensive family of error rates together with a corresponding family of multiple testing procedures (MTP). Based on the needs of the problem at hand, the user can choose a particular member among these MTPs. The new error rate limits the number of false positives FP relative to an arbitrary non-decreasing function s of the number of rejections R. The quantity is called, the scaled false discovery proportion SFDP=FP/s(R). We present different procedures to control either the P(SFDP>q) or the E(SFDP) for any choice of the scaling function. An obvious choice is s(R)=min(R;k). As does FDR, this particular error rate FP/s(R) accepts a fixed percentage of false rejections among all rejections, but only up to R =k, then a stricter control takes over and for R > k, the number of false positives is limited to a percentage of the fixed value k, similar to PFER. The corresponding family of multiple testing procedures bridges the gap between the PFER (k =1) and the FDR (k = number of tests). A similar such bridge is obtained when s(R)=Rg with 0<=g<=1, which for g=0.5 controls the percentage of false discoveries relative to the square root of R. In the talk, we discuss the choice of the parameters k and g based on the minimization of the expected loss t E(FP) - E(TP) = t E(FP) - E(R - FP) which is based on the idea that a false positive costs a penalty of 1<t units, while a true positive corresponds to a gain of 1 unit.

    Keywords: Multiple testing ; LTS5


    • EPFL-TALK-185090

    Record created on 2013-03-18, modified on 2017-05-12


  • There is no available fulltext. Please contact the lab or the authors.

Related material