Lipids and nucleic acids are two of the most abundant components of our cells, and both molecules are widely used as engineering materials for nanoparticles. Here, we present a systematic study of how hydrophobic modifications can be employed to modulate the DNA/lipid interface. Using a series of DNA anchors with increasing hydrophobicity, we quantified the capacity to immobilize double-stranded (ds) DNA to lipid membranes in the liquid phase. Contrary to electrostatic effects, hydrophobic anchors are shown to be phase-independent if sufficiently hydrophobic. For weak anchors, the overall hydrophobicity can be enhanced following the concept of multivalency. Finally, we demonstrate that structural flexibility and anchor orientation overrule the effect of multivalency, emphasizing the need for careful scaffold design if strong interfaces are desired. Together, our findings guide the design of tailored DNA/membrane interfaces, laying the groundwork for advancements in biomaterials, drug delivery vehicles, and synthetic membrane mimics for biomedical research and nanomedicine.