Discomfort glare from daylight: Influence of transmitted color and the eye's macular pigment
Designing architectural façades that allow sufficient daylight to create visually comfortable and pleasant
environments is a challenging aspect of building design. It requires accounting for visual comfort and
discomfort glare risks and understanding the factors that influence them. In the last two decades, several
prediction models have been developed to quantify discomfort glare by considering almost exclusively
the photometric properties and spatial distribution of incoming light. Although these empirical models
have been derived to best match one's perception of glare, they fail to account for the significant interindividual
variability that exists in glare perception and are furthermore limited in their applicability in
certain visual environments. It is evident from the literature that not all the factors influencing
discomfort glare perception are known and accounted for in the existing prediction models. Based on
the literature review, we have identified two potential factors, namely, the macular pigment density in
the retina and the color of daylight, as likely to influence discomfort glare perception. Up to now, their
influence on glare induced by daylight has remained unknown.
To address this gap, this thesis aims to determine the influence of macular pigment density and color of
the sun disc (altered by colored glazing) on discomfort glare perception in daylit environments. By
means of three psychophysical experiments conducted in office-like test rooms along with the ocular
examinations of the participants, we determined the influence of macular pigment and color of daylight
on the perception of discomfort glare for young and healthy individuals. Three experiments were
conducted, one with blue electrochromic glazing, one with color-neutral glazing, and the third with red,
blue, green, and color-neutral glazing. Each experiment followed a similar protocol of exposing every
participant to four daylight glare scenarios and recording their responses to questionnaires. The four
daylight scenarios differed either in color or in the transmittance of the glazing through which the sun
was visible as the primary glare source. The remaining windows were set in a way to keep the overall
color rendering in the space as neutral as possible.
The results show that macular pigment density does not influence discomfort glare perception from the
sun disc filtered by color-neutral glazing in the near-peripheral field of view. However, when exposed
to the sun disc filtered by saturated blue-colored glazing also in the near-peripheral field, participants
with higher macular pigment density were better able to tolerate the glare, indicating a significant
influence of macular pigment in this case.
In regards to the influence of color, results show that the perceived color of the sun disc (as filtered by
colored glazing) has a strong influence on participants' perception of glare. Direct sunlight filtered
through four types of colored glazing of a similar visible (photopic) transmittance caused significantly
different levels of discomfort glare perception amongst the participants. More precisely, participants
experienced statistically higher levels of glare under the red and blue glazing compared to the colorneutral
or green glazing.
The findings show that the photopic luminosity function (V2°(l)) is not an appropriate weighting
function to characterize the spectral sensitivity of the human eye when a high-intensity colored glare
source is in
EPFL_TH10211.pdf
n/a
openaccess
copyright
38.01 MB
Adobe PDF
0bcd2ff05a96aa72a048b02fd6d15e66