Competition between hetero-Diels-Alder and cheletropic addition of sulfur dioxide. Theoretical and experimental substituent effects on the relative stability of 3,6-dihydro-1,2-oxathiin-2-oxides (sultines) and 2,5-dihydrothiophene-1,1-dioxides (sulfolenes). Anomeric effects in sultine and 6-substituted derivatives
At low temperature and in the presence of CF3COOH, SO2 undergoes Diels-Alder additions with (E)-1-acetoxybutadiene (8d) giving a 1:10 mixture of diastereomeric 6-acetoxysultines (9d + 10d). The Van't Hoff plot for equilibria 8d + SO2 reversible arrow 9d + 10d led to Delta H-r = -7.0 +/- 0.3 kcal/mol, Delta S-r = -42 +/- 3 cal . mol(-1) . K-1. At 20 degrees C, 8d underwent a slow cheletropic addition with SO2 giving 2-acetoxysulfolene (11d, Delta Hr congruent to -11.5 kcal/mol), the structure of which was established by single-crystal X-ray diffraction studies. (E)-Chloro (8e) and (E)-bromobutadiene (8f) did not undergo Diels-Alder additions with SO2, even in the presence of protic or Lewis acid promoters. Low yields of 2-chloro- (11e) and 8-bromosulfolene (11f) were obtained at 20 degrees C. The structure of 11e was confirmed by single-crystal X-ray diffraction. The potential energy hypersurfaces of the Diels-Alder and cheletropic additions of SO2 to butadiene (8a), (E)-piperilene (8b), (E)-1-methoxy- (8c), (E)-1-acetoxy- (8d), and (E)-1-chlorobutadiene (8e) were studied by ab initio quantum calculations at the MP2/6-31G* level. In agreement with the experiment, 6-substituted sultines 9X and 10X were less stable than the corresponding 2-substituted sulfolenes 11X for X = Me, OAc, Cl. With X = OMe, the two diastereomeric 6-methoxysultines (9c, 10c) and 8-methoxysulfolene (11c) were calculated to have similar stabilities. This is attributed to a stabilizing thermodynamic anomeric effect or gem-sulfinate/methoxy disubstitution effect in 9c, 10c. Such effects were not detected for sulfinate/acetoxy (9d, 10d) and sulfinate/chloro (9e, 10e) disubstitutions. The relative instability of 8-acetoxy- (11d) and 2-chlorosulfolene (11e) compared with their cycloaddents is attributed to repulsive interactions between the SO2 moieties and the 2-substituents. The Alder endo mode of [4 + 2] cycloaddition of SO2 is predicted to be faster than the "anti-Alder mode" of additions for dienes 8X, X = Me, OMe, OAc, Cl. The resulting diastereomeric sultines 9X and 10X, respectively, exist as equilibria (energy barrier: ca. 5-6 kcal/mol) of two conformers 9X reversible arrow 9X, 10X reversible arrow 10X. In general, the conformers 9X, 10X with pseudoaxial S=O group are preferred (conformational anomeric effect of the sulfinate moiety). Repulsive interactions between pseudoaxial S=O and polar cis-6-substituents (e.g.: X = OMe, OAc) in 9X may render conformers 9X (with the S-O and 6-X groups in pseudoequatorial positions) as stable as conformers 9X. The calculations predict the existence of conformational anomeric effects of 2-3 kcal/mol for the gem-sulfinate/methoxy (9c, 10'c) and gem-sulfinate/acetoxy disubstitution (9d, 10'd).
Univ Oviedo, Dept Quim Fis & Analit, E-33071 Oviedo, Spain. Univ Lausanne, Chim Sect, BCH Dorigny, CH-1015 Lausanne, Switzerland.
Record created on 2005-11-09, modified on 2016-08-08