There is currently no definitive evidence for the implant of choice for the treatment of reverse pertrochanteric fractures. Here, we aimed to compare the stability provided by two implant options: long and short intramedullary nails. We performed finite element simulations of different patterns of reverse pertrochanteric fractures with varying bone quality, and compared the short vs long nail stabilization under physiological loads. For each variable combination, the micromotions at the fracture site, bone strain, and implant stress were computed. Mean micromotions at the fracture surface and absolute and relative fracture surface with micromotions >150 µm were slightly lower with the short nail (8%, 3%, and 3%, respectively). The distal fracture extension negatively affected the stability, with increasing micromotions on the medial side. Bone strain above 1 % was not affected by the nail length. Fatigue stresses were similar for both implants, and no volume was found above the yield and ultimate stress in the tested conditions. This simulation study shows no benefit of long nails for the investigated patterns of reverse pertrochanteric fractures, with similar micromotions at the fracture site, bone strain, and implant stress.