Protein-based materials are biocompatible and have a variety of remarkable properties; consequently, they are finding more and more applications. Nature recycles proteins in multiple ways, ranging from bio-degradation (a slow approach) to fast recycling of protein metabolism. The latter is a wonderful example because a random mixture of proteins gets digested into amino acids (AAs), the fundamental building blocks of proteins. These AAs are then used by cells to produce whichever protein is needed at the time of synthesis. Seen through the lens of recycling, this process transforms a random mixture into something not necessarily present at the start but needed at the moment of recycling. We have recently shown that the process of protein recycling can be performed in vitro and called it NaCRe (Nature Inspired Circular Recycling). In a previous NaCRe proof-of-concept experiment, we started with various protein mixtures but were able to produce only small quantities of recycled protein, in the microgram scale. Here, we show that NaCRe can be used to convert milligrams of a protein mixture containing one of the most common protein materials (silk) into a milligram of an hydrogel made of green fluorescent protein (GFP). We show that in order for NaCRe to be efficient the starting protein mixture must contain a good balance of all AAs and discuss the challenges encountered when scaling up NaCRe.