This page presents the results of the review of over 80 scientific papers where multicriteria decision analysis (MCDA) methods were applied to urban energy system planning problems (see original paper).
The parallel coordinates chart below allows to explore the data collected during the review.
How to use
If you wish to also visualize the references of the corresponding papers, use this chart instead.
Strumming is a 2D selection brushing method, also called pinches by Alfred Inselberg. You start a strum be clicking and dragging within one of the segments (area between two axes). After releasing the mouse button, the selection will contain all lines that pass through all of the active strums.
Abbreviation | Key |
---|---|
AHP |
Analytic Hierarchy Process |
ANP | Analytic Network Process |
ASPID | Analysis and Synthesis of Parameters under Information Deficiency |
COPRAS | COmplex PRoportional ASsessment |
DEMATEL | DEcision MAking Trial and Evaluation Laboratory |
ELECTRE | ELimination Et Choix Traduisant la REalité (from French, ELimination And Choice Transcribing Reality) |
ER | Evidential Reasoning |
FSE | Fuzzy Synthetic Evaluation |
FSEA | Fuzzy Synthetic Extent Analysis |
GC | Global Criterion |
GP | Goal Programming |
HAWM | Hierarchical Additive Weighting Method |
MAUT | Multi-Attribute Utility Theory |
MAVT | Multi-Attribute ValueTheory |
MCS | Multiple Criteria Score |
MEW | Multiplicative Exponential Weighting |
MODM | Multi-Objective Decision Making |
NAIADE | Novel Approach to Imprecise Assessment and Decision Environments |
PROMETHEE | Preference Ranking Organization Method for. Enrichment Evaluations |
PWV | Pseudo-Weight Vector |
SIMUS | Sequential Interactive Modelling for Urban Systems |
SMAA | Stochastic Multiobjective Acceptability Analysis |
SWARA | Step-wise Weight Assessment Ratio Analysis |
TOPSIS | Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solutions |
VIKOR | VIseKriterijumska Optimizacija I kompromisno Resenje (from Serbian, MUltiCriteria Optimization and compromise Solution) |
WASPAS | Weighted Aggregated Sum Product ASsessment |
WSM | Weighted Sum Model |
Abbreviation | Key |
---|---|
BN | Bayesian Network |
CE | Choice Experiment |
CoP | Communities of Practice |
FST | Fuzzy Set Theory |
GIS | Geographic Information System |
IN | Interactive Navigation |
MDA | Membership Degree Analysis |
OWA | Ordered Weighted Averaging |
QCBS | Quality and Cost Based Selection |
SSM | Soft Systems Methodology |
SWOT | Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats |
For credit and further information regarding parallel coordinates charts used above, please visit: https://syntagmatic.github.io/parallel-coordinates/
Paper ID,Author,PublicationDate,PaperTitle,Physical scale,Temporal scale,Planning focus,Problematic,Alternative number,Criteria number,MCDA method,MCDA group,Supporting method,MCDA combination 1,"Fonseca J.A., Nguyen T.-A., Schlueter A., Marechal F.",2016,City Energy Analyst (CEA): Integrated framework for analysis and optimization of building energy systems in neighborhoods and city districts,5. Neighborhood,1. Strategic,2. Integrated/master,Description,Beyond 30,06-10,MODM,4. MODM,,WSM 1,"Fonseca J.A., Nguyen T.-A., Schlueter A., Marechal F.",2016,City Energy Analyst (CEA): Integrated framework for analysis and optimization of building energy systems in neighborhoods and city districts,5. Neighborhood,1. Strategic,2. Integrated/master,Description,Beyond 30,06-10,WSM,1. Value measurement,,MODM 2,"Colantoni A., Delfanti L., Recanatesi F., Tolli M., Lord R.",2016,Land use planning for utilizing biomass residues in Tuscia Romana (central Italy): Preliminary results of a multi criteria analysis to create an agro-energy district,3. Regional,,1. System specific,Choice,Continuous,06-10,,,FST, 2,"Colantoni A., Delfanti L., Recanatesi F., Tolli M., Lord R.",2016,Land use planning for utilizing biomass residues in Tuscia Romana (central Italy): Preliminary results of a multi criteria analysis to create an agro-energy district,3. Regional,,1. System specific,Choice,Continuous,06-10,,,GIS, 3,"Ribau J.P., Sousa J.M.C., Silva C.M.",2015,Reducing the carbon footprint of urban bus fleets using multi-objective optimization,4. City,,1. System specific,Portfolio,Beyond 30,0-5,GC,2. Goal..reference level,,MCS 3,"Ribau J.P., Sousa J.M.C., Silva C.M.",2015,Reducing the carbon footprint of urban bus fleets using multi-objective optimization,4. City,,1. System specific,Portfolio,Beyond 30,0-5,GC,2. Goal..reference level,,MODM 3,"Ribau J.P., Sousa J.M.C., Silva C.M.",2015,Reducing the carbon footprint of urban bus fleets using multi-objective optimization,4. City,,1. System specific,Portfolio,Beyond 30,0-5,GC,2. Goal..reference level,,PWV 3,"Ribau J.P., Sousa J.M.C., Silva C.M.",2015,Reducing the carbon footprint of urban bus fleets using multi-objective optimization,4. City,,1. System specific,Portfolio,Beyond 30,0-5,MCS,5. Other,,GC 3,"Ribau J.P., Sousa J.M.C., Silva C.M.",2015,Reducing the carbon footprint of urban bus fleets using multi-objective optimization,4. City,,1. System specific,Portfolio,Beyond 30,0-5,MCS,5. Other,,MODM 3,"Ribau J.P., Sousa J.M.C., Silva C.M.",2015,Reducing the carbon footprint of urban bus fleets using multi-objective optimization,4. City,,1. System specific,Portfolio,Beyond 30,0-5,MCS,5. Other,,PWV 3,"Ribau J.P., Sousa J.M.C., Silva C.M.",2015,Reducing the carbon footprint of urban bus fleets using multi-objective optimization,4. City,,1. System specific,Portfolio,Beyond 30,0-5,MODM,4. MODM,,GC 3,"Ribau J.P., Sousa J.M.C., Silva C.M.",2015,Reducing the carbon footprint of urban bus fleets using multi-objective optimization,4. City,,1. System specific,Portfolio,Beyond 30,0-5,MODM,4. MODM,,MCS 3,"Ribau J.P., Sousa J.M.C., Silva C.M.",2015,Reducing the carbon footprint of urban bus fleets using multi-objective optimization,4. City,,1. System specific,Portfolio,Beyond 30,0-5,MODM,4. MODM,,PWV 3,"Ribau J.P., Sousa J.M.C., Silva C.M.",2015,Reducing the carbon footprint of urban bus fleets using multi-objective optimization,4. City,,1. System specific,Portfolio,Beyond 30,0-5,PWV,5. Other,,GC 3,"Ribau J.P., Sousa J.M.C., Silva C.M.",2015,Reducing the carbon footprint of urban bus fleets using multi-objective optimization,4. City,,1. System specific,Portfolio,Beyond 30,0-5,PWV,5. Other,,MCS 3,"Ribau J.P., Sousa J.M.C., Silva C.M.",2015,Reducing the carbon footprint of urban bus fleets using multi-objective optimization,4. City,,1. System specific,Portfolio,Beyond 30,0-5,PWV,5. Other,,MODM 4,"Guo S., Zhao H.",2015,Optimal site selection of electric vehicle charging station by using fuzzy TOPSIS based on sustainability perspective,4. City,,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,11-20,TOPSIS,2. Goal..reference level,FST, 5,"Zheng J.H., Chen J.J., Wu Q.H., Jing Z.X.",2015,Multi-objective optimization and decision making for power dispatch of a large-scale integrated energy system with distributed DHCs embedded,5. Neighborhood,,1. System specific,Portfolio,0-5,0-5,ER,5. Other,,MODM 5,"Zheng J.H., Chen J.J., Wu Q.H., Jing Z.X.",2015,Multi-objective optimization and decision making for power dispatch of a large-scale integrated energy system with distributed DHCs embedded,5. Neighborhood,,1. System specific,Portfolio,0-5,0-5,MODM,4. MODM,,ER 7,"Goe M., Gaustad G., Tomaszewski B.",2015,System tradeoffs in siting a solar photovoltaic material recovery infrastructure,2. State,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Sorting,06-10,11-20,MODM,4. MODM,GIS, 8,"Fetanat A., Khorasaninejad E.",2015,A novel hybrid MCDM approach for offshore wind farm site selection: A case study of Iran,3. Regional,,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,31-40,ANP,1. Value measurement,FST,DEMATEL 8,"Fetanat A., Khorasaninejad E.",2015,A novel hybrid MCDM approach for offshore wind farm site selection: A case study of Iran,3. Regional,,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,31-40,ANP,1. Value measurement,FST,ELECTRE 8,"Fetanat A., Khorasaninejad E.",2015,A novel hybrid MCDM approach for offshore wind farm site selection: A case study of Iran,3. Regional,,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,31-40,DEMATEL,5. Other,FST,ANP 8,"Fetanat A., Khorasaninejad E.",2015,A novel hybrid MCDM approach for offshore wind farm site selection: A case study of Iran,3. Regional,,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,31-40,DEMATEL,5. Other,FST,ELECTRE 8,"Fetanat A., Khorasaninejad E.",2015,A novel hybrid MCDM approach for offshore wind farm site selection: A case study of Iran,3. Regional,,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,31-40,ELECTRE,3. Outranking,FST,ANP 8,"Fetanat A., Khorasaninejad E.",2015,A novel hybrid MCDM approach for offshore wind farm site selection: A case study of Iran,3. Regional,,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,31-40,ELECTRE,3. Outranking,FST,DEMATEL 10,"Kontu K., Rinne S., Olkkonen V., Lahdelma R., Salminen P.",2015,Multicriteria evaluation of heating choices for a new sustainable residential area,5. Neighborhood,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,11-20,11-20,SMAA,5. Other,, 11,"Karmellos M., Kiprakis A., Mavrotas G.",2015,"A multi-objective approach for optimal prioritization of energy efficiency measures in buildings: Model, software and case studies",6. Building,,1. System specific,Portfolio,11-20,0-5,MODM,4. MODM,, 12,"Awad-Núñez S., González-Cancelas N., Soler-Flores F., Camarero-Orive A.",2015,How should the sustainability of the location of dry ports be measured? A proposed methodology using Bayesian networks and multi-criteria decision analysis,4. City,,1. System specific,Choice,06-10,Beyond 40,WSM,1. Value measurement,BN, 12,"Awad-Núñez S., González-Cancelas N., Soler-Flores F., Camarero-Orive A.",2015,How should the sustainability of the location of dry ports be measured? A proposed methodology using Bayesian networks and multi-criteria decision analysis,4. City,,1. System specific,Choice,06-10,Beyond 40,WSM,1. Value measurement,Delphi, 12,"Awad-Núñez S., González-Cancelas N., Soler-Flores F., Camarero-Orive A.",2015,How should the sustainability of the location of dry ports be measured? A proposed methodology using Bayesian networks and multi-criteria decision analysis,4. City,,1. System specific,Choice,06-10,Beyond 40,WSM,1. Value measurement,GIS, 13,"Rochas C., Kuz?ecova T., Romagnoli F.",2015,The concept of the system resilience within the infrastructure dimension: Application to a Latvian case,5. Neighborhood,3. Operational,3. Operative,Choice,Beyond 30,0-5,AHP,1. Value measurement,,WSM 13,"Rochas C., Kuz?ecova T., Romagnoli F.",2015,The concept of the system resilience within the infrastructure dimension: Application to a Latvian case,5. Neighborhood,3. Operational,3. Operative,Choice,Beyond 30,0-5,WSM,1. Value measurement,,AHP 14,"Al-Yahyai S., Charabi Y.",2015,Assessment of large-scale wind energy potential in the emerging city of Duqm (Oman),4. City,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,Continuous,06-10,,,FST, 14,"Al-Yahyai S., Charabi Y.",2015,Assessment of large-scale wind energy potential in the emerging city of Duqm (Oman),4. City,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,Continuous,06-10,,,GIS, 16,"Frijns J., Marchet E.C., Carriço N., Covas D., Monteiro A.J., Ramos H.M., Bolognesi A., Bragalli C., Baki S., Makropoulos C.",2015,Management tools for hydro energy interventions in water supply systems,4. City,,3. Operative,Choice,0-5,0-5,ELECTRE III,3. Outranking,,WSM 16,"Frijns J., Marchet E.C., Carriço N., Covas D., Monteiro A.J., Ramos H.M., Bolognesi A., Bragalli C., Baki S., Makropoulos C.",2015,Management tools for hydro energy interventions in water supply systems,4. City,,3. Operative,Choice,0-5,0-5,WSM,1. Value measurement,,ELECTRE III 17,"Meney K., Pantelic L.",2015,Novel decision model for delivering sustainable infrastructure solutions - an australian case study,4. City,1. Strategic,2. Integrated/master,Choice,0-5,11-20,AHP,1. Value measurement,, 18,"Nowak D., Bortz M., Roclawski H.",2015,Decision support for the design and operation of water supply systems,4. City,3. Operational,3. Operative,Portfolio,Beyond 30,0-5,MODM,4. MODM,IN, 19,Öztürk S.,2015,Determining management strategies for the Sarikum Nature Protection Area,3. Regional,,1. System specific,Portfolio,11-20,0-5,RWOT,5. Other,SWOT, 20,"Nixon J.D., Dey P.K., Davies P.A., Sagi S., Berry R.F.",2014,Supply chain optimisation of pyrolysis plant deployment using goal programming,4. City,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,06-10,06-10,GP,2. Goal..reference level,, 21,"Grubert E.A., Stillwell A.S., Webber M.E.",2014,Where does solar-aided seawater desalination make sense? A method for identifying sustainable sites,4. City,,1. System specific,Sorting,Continuous,06-10,,,GIS, 22,"Gruji? M., Ivezi? D., Živkovi? M.",2014,Application of multi-criteria decision-making model for choice of the optimal solution for meeting heat demand in the centralized supply system in Belgrade,4. City,1. Strategic,2. Integrated/master,Choice,0-5,06-10,,,, 23,"Dombi M., Kuti I., Balogh P.",2014,Sustainability assessment of renewable power and heat generation technologies,3. Regional,,1. System specific,Ranking,11-20,06-10,WSM,1. Value measurement,CE, 24,"Vafaeipour M., Hashemkhani Zolfani S., Morshed Varzandeh M.H., Derakhti A., Keshavarz Eshkalag M.",2014,Assessment of regions priority for implementation of solar projects in Iran: New application of a hybrid multi-criteria decision making approach,1. Country,,1. System specific,Ranking,21-30,11-20,SWARA,5. Other,Delphi,WASPAS 24,"Vafaeipour M., Hashemkhani Zolfani S., Morshed Varzandeh M.H., Derakhti A., Keshavarz Eshkalag M.",2014,Assessment of regions priority for implementation of solar projects in Iran: New application of a hybrid multi-criteria decision making approach,1. Country,,1. System specific,Ranking,21-30,11-20,WASPAS,5. Other,Delphi,SWARA 25,"Vu?i?evi? B., Jovanovi? M., Afgan N., Turanjanin V.",2014,Assessing the sustainability of the energy use of residential buildings in Belgrade through multi-criteria analysis,4. City,,1. System specific,Ranking,06-10,11-20,ASPID,1. Value measurement,, 26,"Carriço N.J.G., Veríssimo Gonçalves F., Covas D.I.C., Do Céu Almeida M., Alegre H.",2014,Multi-criteria analysis for the selection of the best energy efficient option in urban water systems,3. Regional,,3. Operative,Ranking,0-5,0-5,ELECTRE III,3. Outranking,,WSM 26,"Carriço N.J.G., Veríssimo Gonçalves F., Covas D.I.C., Do Céu Almeida M., Alegre H.",2014,Multi-criteria analysis for the selection of the best energy efficient option in urban water systems,3. Regional,,3. Operative,Ranking,0-5,0-5,WSM,1. Value measurement,,ELECTRE III 27,"Ma X., Jin J., Lei W.",2014,Multi-criteria analysis of optimal signal plans using microscopic traffic models,5. Neighborhood,,1. System specific,Description,06-10,06-10,MODM,4. MODM,, 28,"Ziemele J., Vigants G., Vitolins V., Blumberga D., Veidenbergs I.",2014,District heating systems performance analyses. Heat energy tariff,1. Country,2. Tactical,3. Operative,Ranking,21-30,06-10,AHP,1. Value measurement,,TOPSIS 28,"Ziemele J., Vigants G., Vitolins V., Blumberga D., Veidenbergs I.",2014,District heating systems performance analyses. Heat energy tariff,1. Country,2. Tactical,3. Operative,Ranking,21-30,06-10,TOPSIS,2. Goal..reference level,,AHP 29,"Jain S., Aggarwal P., Kumar P., Singhal S., Sharma P.",2014,Identifying public preferences using multi-criteria decision making for assessing the shift of urban commuters from private to public transport: A case study of Delhi,4. City,,1. System specific,Description,0-5,11-20,AHP,1. Value measurement,Delphi, 30,"Zhang S., Pan W., Kumaraswamy M.",2014,A multi-criteria decision framework for the selection of low carbon building measures for office buildings in hong kong,6. Building,,1. System specific,Ranking,21-30,11-20,PROMETHEE,3. Outranking,, 31,"Bauer A.M., Brown A.",2014,Quantitative assessment of appropriate technology,5. Neighborhood,,1. System specific,Description,0-5,Beyond 40,WSM,1. Value measurement,Delphi, 32,"Aydin N.Y., Mays L., Schmitt T.",2014,Technical and Environmental Sustainability Assessment of Water Distribution Systems,4. City,,1. System specific,Ranking,06-10,0-5,MODM,4. MODM,,WSM 32,"Aydin N.Y., Mays L., Schmitt T.",2014,Technical and Environmental Sustainability Assessment of Water Distribution Systems,4. City,,1. System specific,Ranking,06-10,0-5,WSM,1. Value measurement,,MODM 33,"Feo G.D., De Gisi S.",2014,Using MCDA and GIS for hazardous waste landfill siting considering land scarcity for waste disposal,3. Regional,,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,11-20,AHP,1. Value measurement,GIS,WSM 33,"Feo G.D., De Gisi S.",2014,Using MCDA and GIS for hazardous waste landfill siting considering land scarcity for waste disposal,3. Regional,,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,11-20,WSM,1. Value measurement,GIS,AHP 35,"Karatas A., El-Rayes K.",2014,Optimal trade-offs between social quality of life and life-cycle cost in housing units,6. Building,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Portfolio,Beyond 30,11-20,MODM,4. MODM,, 39,"Madadian E., Amiri L., Abdoli M.A.",2013,Application of analytic hierarchy process and multicriteria decision analysis on waste management: A case study in iran,4. City,2. Tactical,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,06-10,AHP,1. Value measurement,, 43,"Chrysoulakis N., Lopes M., San José R., Grimmond C.S.B., Jones M.B., Magliulo V., Klostermann J.E.M., Synnefa A., Mitraka Z., Castro E.A., González A., Vogt R., Vesala T., Spano D., Pigeon G., Freer-Smith P., Staszewski T., Hodges N., Mills G., Cartalis C.",2013,Sustainable urban metabolism as a link between bio-physical sciences and urban planning: The BRIDGE project,4. City,1. Strategic,2. Integrated/master,Choice,0-5,31-40,AHP,1. Value measurement,CoP, 44,"Daim T.U., Bhatla A., Mansour M.",2013,Site selection for a data centre - a multi-criteria decision-making model,1. Country,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,11-20,AHP,1. Value measurement,, 46,"González A., Donnelly A., Jones M., Chrysoulakis N., Lopes M.",2013,A decision-support system for sustainable urban metabolism in Europe,5. Neighborhood,,2. Integrated/master,Choice,0-5,31-40,AHP,1. Value measurement,CoP, 46,"González A., Donnelly A., Jones M., Chrysoulakis N., Lopes M.",2013,A decision-support system for sustainable urban metabolism in Europe,5. Neighborhood,,2. Integrated/master,Choice,0-5,31-40,AHP,1. Value measurement,GIS, 47,"Rager J., Dorsaz C., Maréchal F.",2013,ECOS: Integrated and practical energy planning for new districts,5. Neighborhood,1. Strategic,2. Integrated/master,Description,06-10,06-10,MODM,4. MODM,, 48,"Li H.-Q., Parriaux A., Thalmann P.",2013,"The way to flan a sustainable ""deep city"": The economic model and strategic framework",4. City,,1. System specific,Sorting,06-10,06-10,,,, 49,Gargiulo C.,2013,Performance oriented building assessment: A decision-support method based on an integrated approach,6. Building,,1. System specific,Description,0-5,Beyond 40,,,, 50,"Al-Ani D., Habibi S.",2013,Optimal operation of water pumping stations,4. City,3. Operational,3. Operative,Description,0-5,0-5,MODM,4. MODM,, 52,"Karatas A., El-Rayes K.",2013,Optimizing tradeoffs among housing sustainability objectives,6. Building,1. Strategic,2. Integrated/master,Portfolio,Beyond 30,11-20,AHP,1. Value measurement,,MAUT 52,"Karatas A., El-Rayes K.",2013,Optimizing tradeoffs among housing sustainability objectives,6. Building,1. Strategic,2. Integrated/master,Portfolio,Beyond 30,11-20,AHP,1. Value measurement,,MODM 52,"Karatas A., El-Rayes K.",2013,Optimizing tradeoffs among housing sustainability objectives,6. Building,1. Strategic,2. Integrated/master,Portfolio,Beyond 30,11-20,MAUT,1. Value measurement,,AHP 52,"Karatas A., El-Rayes K.",2013,Optimizing tradeoffs among housing sustainability objectives,6. Building,1. Strategic,2. Integrated/master,Portfolio,Beyond 30,11-20,MAUT,1. Value measurement,,MODM 52,"Karatas A., El-Rayes K.",2013,Optimizing tradeoffs among housing sustainability objectives,6. Building,1. Strategic,2. Integrated/master,Portfolio,Beyond 30,11-20,MODM,4. MODM,,AHP 52,"Karatas A., El-Rayes K.",2013,Optimizing tradeoffs among housing sustainability objectives,6. Building,1. Strategic,2. Integrated/master,Portfolio,Beyond 30,11-20,MODM,4. MODM,,MAUT 53,"Perez M.G.R., Rey E.",2012,Comparative multi-criteria assessment of urban renewal scenarios for existing neighbourhoods,5. Neighborhood,,2. Integrated/master,Description,0-5,06-10,,,, 54,"De Sousa L., Eykamp C., Leopold U., Baume O., Braun C.",2012,IGUESS - A web based system integrating urban energy planning and assessment modelling for multi-scale spatial decision making,4. City,,2. Integrated/master,Description,0-5,0-5,,,, 55,"Vadiati M., Kabiri M., Nekouei F., Ebrahimi A.R.",2012,A new solution for space saving of substations in Tehran Regional Electric Company,6. Building,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,06-10,WSM,1. Value measurement,QCBS, 56,Ma X.,2012,Multi-criteria evaluation of optimal signal strategies using traffic simulation and evolutionary algorithms,5. Neighborhood,,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,0-5,MODM,4. MODM,, 58,"Idris R., Abd. Latif Z.",2012,GIS multi-criteria for power plant site selection,3. Regional,,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,06-10,AHP,1. Value measurement,GIS, 59,"Pérez-Fortes M., Laínez-Aguirre J.M., Arranz-Piera P., Velo E., Puigjaner L.",2012,Design of regional and sustainable bio-based networks for electricity generation using a multi-objective MILP approach,3. Regional,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Portfolio,Beyond 30,0-5,MODM,4. MODM,, 60,"Al-Yahyai S., Charabi Y., Gastli A., Al-Badi A.",2012,Wind farm land suitability indexing using multi-criteria analysis,1. Country,,1. System specific,Choice,Continuous,06-10,AHP,1. Value measurement,FST, 60,"Al-Yahyai S., Charabi Y., Gastli A., Al-Badi A.",2012,Wind farm land suitability indexing using multi-criteria analysis,1. Country,,1. System specific,Choice,Continuous,06-10,AHP,1. Value measurement,GIS, 60,"Al-Yahyai S., Charabi Y., Gastli A., Al-Badi A.",2012,Wind farm land suitability indexing using multi-criteria analysis,1. Country,,1. System specific,Choice,Continuous,06-10,AHP,1. Value measurement,OWA, 61,"Khoshsolat S.A., Aziz N.A., Ismail N., Adam N.",2012,Repositioning of electric distribution substations using fuzzy decision making,4. City,,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,0-5,AHP,1. Value measurement,FST,TOPSIS 61,"Khoshsolat S.A., Aziz N.A., Ismail N., Adam N.",2012,Repositioning of electric distribution substations using fuzzy decision making,4. City,,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,0-5,TOPSIS,2. Goal..reference level,FST,AHP 65,"Wu W., Simpson A.R., Maier H.R., Marchi A.",2012,Incorporation of variable-speed pumping in multiobjective genetic algorithm optimization of the design of water transmission systems,4. City,2. Tactical,3. Operative,Portfolio,0-5,0-5,MODM,4. MODM,, 68,"Hsu T.P., Lin Y.T.",2011,A model for planning a bicycle network with multi-criteria suitability evaluation using GIS,4. City,,1. System specific,Sorting,Beyond 30,06-10,AHP,1. Value measurement,FST, 68,"Hsu T.P., Lin Y.T.",2011,A model for planning a bicycle network with multi-criteria suitability evaluation using GIS,4. City,,1. System specific,Sorting,Beyond 30,06-10,AHP,1. Value measurement,GIS, 69,"Van Haaren R., Fthenakis V.",2011,GIS-based wind farm site selection using spatial multi-criteria analysis (SMCA): Evaluating the case for New York State,2. State,,1. System specific,Ranking,Continuous,11-20,,,GIS, 70,"Hsueh S.-L., Yan M.-R.",2011,Enhancing sustainable community developments: A multi-criteria evaluation model for energy efficient project selection,5. Neighborhood,,2. Integrated/master,Choice,0-5,06-10,AHP,1. Value measurement,Delphi, 70,"Hsueh S.-L., Yan M.-R.",2011,Enhancing sustainable community developments: A multi-criteria evaluation model for energy efficient project selection,5. Neighborhood,,2. Integrated/master,Choice,0-5,06-10,AHP,1. Value measurement,FST, 71,"Wang L., Xu L., Song H.",2011,Environmental performance evaluation of Beijing's energy use planning,4. City,2. Tactical,2. Integrated/master,Ranking,0-5,11-20,AHP,1. Value measurement,FST,FSEA 71,"Wang L., Xu L., Song H.",2011,Environmental performance evaluation of Beijing's energy use planning,4. City,2. Tactical,2. Integrated/master,Ranking,0-5,11-20,AHP,1. Value measurement,MDA,FSEA 71,"Wang L., Xu L., Song H.",2011,Environmental performance evaluation of Beijing's energy use planning,4. City,2. Tactical,2. Integrated/master,Ranking,0-5,11-20,FSEA,5. Other,FST,AHP 71,"Wang L., Xu L., Song H.",2011,Environmental performance evaluation of Beijing's energy use planning,4. City,2. Tactical,2. Integrated/master,Ranking,0-5,11-20,FSEA,5. Other,MDA,AHP 72,"Duan Z., Pang Z., Wang X.",2011,"Sustainability evaluation of limestone geothermal reservoirs with extended production histories in Beijing and Tianjin, China",4. City,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Description,0-5,06-10,AHP,1. Value measurement,FST,FSE 72,"Duan Z., Pang Z., Wang X.",2011,"Sustainability evaluation of limestone geothermal reservoirs with extended production histories in Beijing and Tianjin, China",4. City,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Description,0-5,06-10,FSE,5. Other,FST,AHP 73,"Jovanovic M., Turanjanin V., Bakic V., Pezo M., Vucicevic B.",2011,Sustainability estimation of energy system options that use gas and renewable resources for domestic hot water production,4. City,,1. System specific,Description,0-5,11-20,ASPID,1. Value measurement,, 74,"Reza B., Sadiq R., Hewage K.",2011,Sustainability assessment of flooring systems in the city of Tehran: An AHP-based life cycle analysis,4. City,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,11-20,AHP,1. Value measurement,, 76,"Medineckiene M., Björk F.",2011,Owner preferences regarding renovation measures - The demonstration of using multi-criteria decision making,6. Building,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,11-20,0-5,AHP,1. Value measurement,,COPRAS 76,"Medineckiene M., Björk F.",2011,Owner preferences regarding renovation measures - The demonstration of using multi-criteria decision making,6. Building,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,11-20,0-5,AHP,1. Value measurement,,MEW 76,"Medineckiene M., Björk F.",2011,Owner preferences regarding renovation measures - The demonstration of using multi-criteria decision making,6. Building,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,11-20,0-5,AHP,1. Value measurement,,WSM 76,"Medineckiene M., Björk F.",2011,Owner preferences regarding renovation measures - The demonstration of using multi-criteria decision making,6. Building,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,11-20,0-5,COPRAS,5. Other,,AHP 76,"Medineckiene M., Björk F.",2011,Owner preferences regarding renovation measures - The demonstration of using multi-criteria decision making,6. Building,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,11-20,0-5,COPRAS,5. Other,,MEW 76,"Medineckiene M., Björk F.",2011,Owner preferences regarding renovation measures - The demonstration of using multi-criteria decision making,6. Building,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,11-20,0-5,COPRAS,5. Other,,WSM 76,"Medineckiene M., Björk F.",2011,Owner preferences regarding renovation measures - The demonstration of using multi-criteria decision making,6. Building,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,11-20,0-5,MEW,1. Value measurement,,AHP 76,"Medineckiene M., Björk F.",2011,Owner preferences regarding renovation measures - The demonstration of using multi-criteria decision making,6. Building,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,11-20,0-5,MEW,1. Value measurement,,COPRAS 76,"Medineckiene M., Björk F.",2011,Owner preferences regarding renovation measures - The demonstration of using multi-criteria decision making,6. Building,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,11-20,0-5,MEW,1. Value measurement,,WSM 76,"Medineckiene M., Björk F.",2011,Owner preferences regarding renovation measures - The demonstration of using multi-criteria decision making,6. Building,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,11-20,0-5,WSM,1. Value measurement,,AHP 76,"Medineckiene M., Björk F.",2011,Owner preferences regarding renovation measures - The demonstration of using multi-criteria decision making,6. Building,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,11-20,0-5,WSM,1. Value measurement,,COPRAS 76,"Medineckiene M., Björk F.",2011,Owner preferences regarding renovation measures - The demonstration of using multi-criteria decision making,6. Building,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,11-20,0-5,WSM,1. Value measurement,,MEW 78,"Massara V.M., Udaeta M.E.M.",2010,Multi-criteria evaluation of the expansion of natural gas distribution network by the urban dynamics,4. City,,1. System specific,Ranking,06-10,21-30,AHP,1. Value measurement,, 80,"Banar M., Özkan A., Kulaç A.",2010,Choosing a recycling system using ANP and ELECTRE III techniques,4. City,,1. System specific,Portfolio,0-5,11-20,ANP,1. Value measurement,,ELECTRE III 80,"Banar M., Özkan A., Kulaç A.",2010,Choosing a recycling system using ANP and ELECTRE III techniques,4. City,,1. System specific,Portfolio,0-5,11-20,ELECTRE III,3. Outranking,,ANP 81,Phdungsilp A.,2010,Integrated energy and carbon modeling with a decision support system: Policy scenarios for low-carbon city development in Bangkok,4. City,1. Strategic,2. Integrated/master,Description,11-20,11-20,MAVT,1. Value measurement,, 82,"Jovanovic M., Afgan N., Bakic V.",2010,An analytical method for the measurement of energy system sustainability in urban areas,4. City,1. Strategic,2. Integrated/master,Choice,0-5,11-20,ASPID,1. Value measurement,, 84.1,"Ekmekçio?lu M., Kaya T., Kahraman C.",2010,Fuzzy multicriteria disposal method and site selection for municipal solid waste,4. City,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,06-10,AHP,1. Value measurement,FST,TOPSIS 84.1,"Ekmekçio?lu M., Kaya T., Kahraman C.",2010,Fuzzy multicriteria disposal method and site selection for municipal solid waste,4. City,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,06-10,TOPSIS,2. Goal..reference level,FST,AHP 84.2,"Ekmekçio?lu M., Kaya T., Kahraman C.",2010,Fuzzy multicriteria disposal method and site selection for municipal solid waste,4. City,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,06-10,AHP,1. Value measurement,FST,TOPSIS 84.2,"Ekmekçio?lu M., Kaya T., Kahraman C.",2010,Fuzzy multicriteria disposal method and site selection for municipal solid waste,4. City,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,06-10,TOPSIS,2. Goal..reference level,FST,AHP 85,"Sheykhdavodi M.J., Nik M.A.E., Bilondi M.P., Atashi M., Seyedian S.M.",2010,Mechanization planning for tillage of saffron fields using multiple criteria ecision-making technique as a policy framework in Iran,4. City,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,06-10,HAWM,1. Value measurement,, 86.1,"Kaya T., Kahraman C.",2010,Multicriteria renewable energy planning using an integrated fuzzy VIKOR & AHP methodology: The case of Istanbul,4. City,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Ranking,0-5,06-10,AHP,1. Value measurement,FST,VIKOR 86.1,"Kaya T., Kahraman C.",2010,Multicriteria renewable energy planning using an integrated fuzzy VIKOR & AHP methodology: The case of Istanbul,4. City,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Ranking,0-5,06-10,VIKOR,2. Goal..reference level,FST,AHP 86.2,"Kaya T., Kahraman C.",2010,Multicriteria renewable energy planning using an integrated fuzzy VIKOR & AHP methodology: The case of Istanbul,4. City,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Ranking,06-10,06-10,AHP,1. Value measurement,FST,VIKOR 86.2,"Kaya T., Kahraman C.",2010,Multicriteria renewable energy planning using an integrated fuzzy VIKOR & AHP methodology: The case of Istanbul,4. City,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Ranking,06-10,06-10,VIKOR,2. Goal..reference level,FST,AHP 88,"Ghafghazi S., Sowlati T., Sokhansanj S., Melin S.",2010,A multicriteria approach to evaluate district heating system options,5. Neighborhood,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Ranking,0-5,06-10,PROMETHEE,3. Outranking,, 89,"Browne D., O'Regan B., Moles R.",2010,Use of multi-criteria decision analysis to explore alternative domestic energy and electricity policy scenarios in an Irish city-region,4. City,1. Strategic,2. Integrated/master,Description,06-10,06-10,NAIADE,3. Outranking,, 90,Afify A.,2010,Prioritizing desalination strategies using multi-criteria decision analysis,1. Country,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Ranking,21-30,0-5,WSM,1. Value measurement,, 91,"Coelho D., Antunes C.H., Martins A.G.",2010,Using SSM for structuring decision support in urban energy planning [Operacin?s sistemos metodologijos taikymas planuojant miesto energetika{ogonek}],4. City,,2. Integrated/master,Sorting,0-5,0-5,ELECTRE TRI,3. Outranking,SSM, 92,"Nigim K., Reiser H., Luiken M.",2009,Alternatives prioritization tool for sustainable urban energy management,4. City,,1. System specific,Ranking,06-10,06-10,AHP,1. Value measurement,, 93,"Ayoub N., Elmoshi E., Seki H., Naka Y.",2009,Evolutionary algorithms approach for integrated bioenergy supply chains optimization,4. City,,1. System specific,Portfolio,Beyond 30,0-5,MODM,4. MODM,, 95,"Jovanovi? M., Afgan N., Radovanovi? P., Stevanovi? V.",2009,Sustainable development of the Belgrade energy system,4. City,1. Strategic,2. Integrated/master,Ranking,0-5,11-20,WSM,1. Value measurement,, 96,"Karagiannidis A., Perkoulidis G.",2009,A multi-criteria ranking of different technologies for the anaerobic digestion for energy recovery of the organic fraction of municipal solid wastes,3. Regional,,1. System specific,Ranking,0-5,0-5,ELECTRE III,3. Outranking,, 98,"Bent E.M., Hiatt R., Singa K.",2008,"Full-featured bus rapid transit in San Francisco, California toward a comprehensive planning approach and evaluation framework",4. City,2. Tactical,1. System specific,Description,0-5,06-10,,,, 100,"Bottero M., Mondini G.",2008,An appraisal of analytic network process and its role in sustainability assessment in Northern Italy,4. City,,2. Integrated/master,Ranking,0-5,11-20,ANP,1. Value measurement,, 101,"De Feo G., De Gisi S., Galasso M.",2008,Definition of a practical multi-criteria procedure for selecting the best coagulant in a chemically assisted primary sedimentation process for the treatment of urban wastewater,4. City,,3. Operative,Choice,11-20,0-5,AHP,1. Value measurement,,WSM 101,"De Feo G., De Gisi S., Galasso M.",2008,Definition of a practical multi-criteria procedure for selecting the best coagulant in a chemically assisted primary sedimentation process for the treatment of urban wastewater,4. City,,3. Operative,Choice,11-20,0-5,WSM,1. Value measurement,,AHP 102,"Koo D.-H., Ariaratnam S.T.",2008,Application of a sustainability model for assessing water main replacement options,4. City,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,06-10,AHP,1. Value measurement,,WSM 102,"Koo D.-H., Ariaratnam S.T.",2008,Application of a sustainability model for assessing water main replacement options,4. City,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,06-10,WSM,1. Value measurement,,AHP 105,"Haruvy N., Shalhevet S.",2007,Risk assessment of the effect of wastewater treatment and desalination processes on the coastal aquifer in Israel: Using multi-criteria decision analysis,3. Regional,,1. System specific,Ranking,0-5,06-10,WSM,1. Value measurement,Delphi, 106,"Murphy J., O'Cinneide D.",2006,Evaluation of urban transport management,4. City,,1. System specific,Description,06-10,11-20,n/a,,, 107,"Lipoš?ak M., Afgan N.H., Dui? N., da Graça Carvalho M.",2006,Sustainability assessment of cogeneration sector development in Croatia,1. Country,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Description,0-5,06-10,ASPID,1. Value measurement,, 109,"Dytczak M., Ginda G.",2006,Benefits and costs in selecting fuel for municipality heating systems with the analytic hierarchy process,4. City,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Choice,0-5,11-20,AHP,1. Value measurement,, 112,"Tzeng G.-H., Lin C.-W., Opricovic S.",2005,Multi-criteria analysis of alternative-fuel buses for public transportation,4. City,,1. System specific,Ranking,11-20,11-20,AHP,1. Value measurement,Delphi,TOPSIS 112,"Tzeng G.-H., Lin C.-W., Opricovic S.",2005,Multi-criteria analysis of alternative-fuel buses for public transportation,4. City,,1. System specific,Ranking,11-20,11-20,AHP,1. Value measurement,Delphi,VIKOR 112,"Tzeng G.-H., Lin C.-W., Opricovic S.",2005,Multi-criteria analysis of alternative-fuel buses for public transportation,4. City,,1. System specific,Ranking,11-20,11-20,TOPSIS,2. Goal..reference level,Delphi,AHP 112,"Tzeng G.-H., Lin C.-W., Opricovic S.",2005,Multi-criteria analysis of alternative-fuel buses for public transportation,4. City,,1. System specific,Ranking,11-20,11-20,TOPSIS,2. Goal..reference level,Delphi,VIKOR 112,"Tzeng G.-H., Lin C.-W., Opricovic S.",2005,Multi-criteria analysis of alternative-fuel buses for public transportation,4. City,,1. System specific,Ranking,11-20,11-20,VIKOR,2. Goal..reference level,Delphi,AHP 112,"Tzeng G.-H., Lin C.-W., Opricovic S.",2005,Multi-criteria analysis of alternative-fuel buses for public transportation,4. City,,1. System specific,Ranking,11-20,11-20,VIKOR,2. Goal..reference level,Delphi,TOPSIS 116,"Nigim K., Munier N., Green J.",2004,Pre-feasibility MCDM tools to aid communities in prioritizing local viable renewable energy sources,5. Neighborhood,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Ranking,0-5,06-10,AHP,1. Value measurement,,SIMUS 116,"Nigim K., Munier N., Green J.",2004,Pre-feasibility MCDM tools to aid communities in prioritizing local viable renewable energy sources,5. Neighborhood,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Ranking,0-5,06-10,SIMUS,2. Goal..reference level,,AHP 117,"Arampatzis G., Kiranoudis C.T., Scaloubacas P., Assimacopoulos D.",2004,A GIS-based decision support system for planning urban transportation policies,4. City,,1. System specific,Sorting,0-5,11-20,WSM,1. Value measurement,GIS, 118,"Yedla S., Shrestha R.M.",2003,Multi-criteria approach for the selection of alternative options for environmentally sustainable transport system in Delhi,4. City,,1. System specific,Ranking,0-5,06-10,AHP,1. Value measurement,, 120,"Beccali G., Cellura M., Mistretta M.",2002,A user-friendly software for sustainable management of urban areas,4. City,,2. Integrated/master,Choice,0-5,06-10,AHP,1. Value measurement,,WSM 120,"Beccali G., Cellura M., Mistretta M.",2002,A user-friendly software for sustainable management of urban areas,4. City,,2. Integrated/master,Choice,0-5,06-10,WSM,1. Value measurement,,AHP 126,"Yokoyama R., Ito K.",1995,Multi-objective optimization in unit sizing of a gas turbine cogeneration plant,5. Neighborhood,1. Strategic,1. System specific,Portfolio,06-10,0-5,MODM,4. MODM,, 127,"Videla S., Chamy R., Navarrete E., Lema J.M.",1990,Design and operation of anaerobic digesters using multi-objective optimization criteria,4. City,,1. System specific,Portfolio,11-20,0-5,MODM,4. MODM,